In the international trade of fresh fruit and vegetables, where shelf life dictates the pace of every shipment, a single documentary or logistical failure can compromise an entire operation. That is the view of Carla González Santalucía, Head of the Customs Department, and Carlos González Calcaño, lawyer and Commercial Director at Blas de Lezo, a firm specializing in maritime, customs, and port law, who analyze the vulnerabilities of the perishable supply chain.
“Contractual prevention and customs rigor safeguard commercial margins against inspections, delays, and foreign non-payment.”
© Hapag-Lloyd
Customs origin and documentary challenges
One of the most common disputes in customs clearance arises when determining the origin of goods within increasingly fragmented international supply chains. Carla González Santalucía explains that it is essential to distinguish between the country where the produce is grown and harvested, the country from which it is shipped, and the territory where it is merely handled, sorted, or packed.
“There are specific rules for establishing origin based on the product and the processes applied, and confusing these concepts leads to the loss of tariff preferences, additional duty assessments, and customs problems.”
This technical requirement has intensified, for example, in exports to the United Kingdom following Brexit, a scenario that imposes border controls and third-country requirements. Carla notes that the greatest operational obstacles are concentrated in phytosanitary certificates, pre-notifications, and the coordination of per-consignment inspections. Forward planning is critical for perishable products: “a minor documentary discrepancy can hold a truck at the border, so the challenge is to resolve all requirements before reaching the destination.”
© Blas de Lezo
Carla González Santalucía and Carlos González Calcaño of Blas de Lezo
Port holds and cold chain breaks
When a consignment is held at a border or port, the immediate response must combine operational speed with rigorous documentation to contain the financial damage.
The priority is to protect the goods by securing refrigeration, power supply, temperature records, and an urgent inspection, once the reason for the hold and the custody arrangements have been identified, explains Carlos González. “It is worth considering an alternative outlet or salvage sale without waiting to establish who will bear the cost, in order to reduce losses, while documenting all decisions and expenses, or transferring the cargo to a Temporary Storage Facility to cut costs while the authorities reach a decision.”
In cases of cold chain breaks or delays, it is advisable to analyze each situation separately, distinguishing between sale-of-goods risk and transport liability, since the party liable under one contract may be able to pass that liability on under the other. Refrigeration failures, insufficient pre-cooling, poor stowage, incorrect instructions, and hot stuffing practices attributable to the shipper are among the most frequent causes.
“A photograph of the damage can never replace a complete temperature traceability record. It is vital to notify the responsible parties and the insurer in writing, lodge reservations within the applicable time limits, three days in maritime transport for non-apparent damage, and request a joint survey,” says Carlos, stressing the value of technical evidence from the very first sign of a problem.
© Mr.siwabud Veerapaisarn | Dreamstime
Legal deadlines, Incoterms, and recovering foreign debts
Claims are governed by two separate procedural clocks that require action from day one: formally notifying the damage and bringing legal proceedings. Under road transport governed by the CMR Convention, apparent damage must be reserved at delivery, non-apparent damage within seven working days in writing, and delay within twenty-one days, with the right of action expiring after one year.
In maritime transport, where an email does not preserve rights indefinitely, it is necessary to gather temperature records, instructions, transport documents, surveys, and evidence of value and residual recovery, bearing in mind that sale-of-goods claims have a ten-year limitation period compared with the standard one year for transport claims.
To prevent disputes, Carlos González of Blas de Lezo explains that Incoterms (international commercial terms) allocate costs and risks by specifying the rule, version, and named place, but they can never replace a contract that is properly coordinated with transport and insurance arrangements and that defines quality, size, maturity, tolerances, temperature, payment, dispute resolution, and protocols for rejected consignments.
When a foreign non-payment arises, the strategy requires first identifying where the debtor holds attachable assets before filing a claim, without prolonging negotiations that could jeopardize time limits. While an agreement with a debt acknowledgment and guarantees is preferable, the European Payment Order procedure speeds up the recovery of undisputed debts within the European Union. From the outset, it is advisable to agree on forums with mutual recognition, such as Maritime Arbitration in London or the Transport Arbitration Boards in Spain for amounts below fifteen thousand euros.
A recent case in Barcelona illustrates the point: an Ecuadorian container bypassed the Border Inspection Post on its way to the warehouse and ended up being redirected to destruction, re-export, or by-product use such as animal feed and fertilizer, after costs were recovered. “In such a strictly regulated industry, any logistical omission can cost thousands of euros without specialist advice.”
For more information:
Blas de Lezo
Carla González Santalucia
Calle de la Garrotxa, 6, 1-3, 08820 – El Prat de Llobregat (Barcelona)
T: +34 934192489
[email protected]
www.bdlezo.com
